Portrayal in a False Light


The portrayal in a false light privacy tort involves publishing highly offensive private information about an individual to create a bad impression.

  • information published is true, but it is published in an offensive way
  • often is confused with defamation
    • another type of tort that involves maliciously saying false things about another person
  • portrayal in a false light privacy tort occurs when a person’s photograph or image is used to create a bad impression
    • E.g.,
      • taking a picture for a magazine of a person standing outside of a bar might create the impression that the person is a customer
      • which might be offensive if the person holds a position of high respect in the community
      • person photographed could sue for invasion of privacy based on portrayal in a false light

Example

In 1993, the Alabama Supreme Court reviewed a false light case.

  • a greyhound racetrack took a picture of a group of men sitting together
  • was later used in advertising material
  • men sued for false light
  • court held that the men did not state a claim for false light because they were in a public place
  • court said there was nothing offensive about sitting at the track
  • also said that the men consented to the taking of the photograph because they did not move or object when the photographer appeared and began taking pictures
  • These types of torts are very dependent on the facts and circumstances of each case