Authority to Collect Evidence


The Fourth Amendment and Search Warrants

  • Fourth Amendment protects people from unreasonable government search and seizure where a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy
    • A search happens when a person’s reasonable expectation of privacy in a place or thing is compromised
    • A seizure happens when the government interferes with a person’s property
  • United States v. Heckenkamp held that people have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their personal computer
  • Supreme Court held that a warrant is required before searching a cell phone
    • and for searching its location information stored by the service provider

Requirements For a Warrant

  • clearly specify the criminal activity being investigated
  • describe where the search will take place
  • list the items that will be searched
  • state the evidence that they expect to find
  • state how that evidence relates to the criminal activity

Exceptions to The Fourth Amendment’s Search Warrant Requirements

  • Consent
  • Plain view doctrine
    • does not need a warrant to search and seize evidence that is in an officer’s “plain view”
    • must be able to see the evidence from a place where the officer has a right to be
  • Exigent circumstances
    • allowed to make a warrantless search and seizure in emergency circumstances
    • applies if
      • public safety would be harmed
      • or evidence would be destroyed if law enforcement took the time to go to court to get a warrant
  • Search incident to a lawful arrest
    • does not need a warrant to search for weapons or contraband on the body of an arrested person
    • search nearby area for accomplices
    • this is to protect their own safety
    • aka protective sweep exception
  • Inventory search
    • may conduct inventory searches without a warrant when they arrest a suspect
    • allowed when they are made for a non-investigative purpose
    • E.g.,
      • may seize the computer for safekeeping while the suspect is in custody
    • must have standard policies and procedures for conducting inventory searches
    • must document the search
  • 4th Amendment allows for seizure of physical media without a warrant, but need one to authorize a forensic examination

Federal Laws Regarding Electronic Data Collection