Security Appliance Attributes


  • Attributes determine the precise way in which a device can be placed within the network topology

Active vs Passive

A passive security control is one that does not require any sort of client or agent configuration or host data transfer to operate.

  • e.g., network traffic can be directed or copied to a sensor and scanned by an analysis engine

An active security control that performs scanning must be configured with credentials and access permissions and exchange data with target hosts.

  • requires hosts to be explicitly configured to use the control
    • e.g.,
      • installing agent software on the host
      • or configuring network settings to use the control as a gateway
  • allows for more accurate credentialed scanning
    • consumes some host resources
    • is detectable by threat actors

Inline Devices and Monitor Methods

Inline device is the placement and configuration of a network security control so that it becomes part of the cable path.

  • No changes in the IP or routing topology are required
  • device’s interfaces are not configured with MAC or IP addresses
  • can copy network traffic to a monitor or sensor
    • A monitor that records (or “sniffs”) data from frames as they pass over network media, using methods such as a mirror port or TAP device
    • can be configured to receive traffic in two different ways:

Fail-Open vs Fail-Closed

  • A security device could enter a failure state for a number of reasons
    • hardware failure
    • software failure
    • configuration issues
    • natural disasters
  • device can be configured to fail-open or fail-closed:
    • fail-open
      • ensures continued access to the resource in the event of failure
      • prioritizes availability over confidentiality and integrity
      • risk:
        • threat actor could engineer a failure state to defeat the control
    • fail-closed
      • blocks access to a resource in the event of failure
      • enters the most secure state available
      • prioritizes confidentiality and integrity over availability
      • risk is system downtime