Peer Review


Peer review is a method of validating data that involves gaining feedback from others before publication.

  • practical way to gain feedback on the data product before it is published or goes live
  • can be:
    • as simple as having someone walk through your presentation and provide suggestions for improvement
    • as complex as running a deep review to test if your results are repeatable and accurate
  • ultimate goal of peer review is to make sure that what you’re reporting is accurate
  • In published studies, peer review has a more formalized structure, with required third-party validation
  • ISO and NIST offer standards and activities for a formal peer review process
  • ISO/IEC 20246 is dedicated to work product review
    • is a generic process that can be used for projects in the realm of software and the lifecycle of data